K Srinivasan
Seven years ago, in February 2019, Anil Ambani was held guilty of contempt of court by a Supreme Court Bench led by Justice Rohinton F Nariman. In a landmark ruling, the Supreme Court delivered a mighty blow to the Reliance Communications (RCom) Chairman, slamming his legal strategy as a deliberate, calculated design to stall payments and subvert the judicial process.
The dispute concerned outstanding dues owed to Swedish telecom equipment major Ericsson. RCom had given an unconditional undertaking to the Supreme Court to clear Rs 550 crore in liabilities but repeatedly missed payment deadlines. Justice Nariman’s Bench fiercely castigated Ambani for using “subterfuge” to evade commitments. In fact, the court went so far as to state that he had played fast and loose with the court’s solemn orders. As a result, the court ordered Ambani to pay the remaining balance of Rs 453 crore to Ericsson within a non-negotiable four-week window. Any failure to meet this deadline, the Bench stated explicitly, would result in a mandatory three-month civil prison sentence for Ambani and two senior group executives.
The crisis was averted at the final hour when his elder brother, Mukesh Ambani, intervened to clear the pending dues.
Not much learnt
Cut to seven years later, not much has been learnt from that landmark judgement. On November 2, to quote The Hindustan Times: “The Supreme Court dismissed the Union Government’s appeal against a Delhi High Court order allowing Vedanta Ltd and Ravva Oil (Singapore) Pvt Ltd to enforce foreign arbitration awards involving claims of $99 million, criticising the Centre for resisting enforcement of awards that date back more than two decades and warning that such litigation could undermine confidence in India’s arbitration regime.’’
By all accounts, courts easily recognise subterfuge. The issue is that highly-paid lawyers present subterfuge in a delectable dressing described as procedure. Delays are no longer sought by defying judicial orders, but by systematically expanding the legal roots, reviews, appeals, objections, and technical challenges. And the goal is the same: not to win the argument, but to postpone the consequences of losing it.
The Ericsson-RCom outlined how the Supreme Court was fully aware of this tactic. Justice Nariman’s rebuke was directed not merely at a failure to pay, but at what the court considered a systematic and deliberate attempt to use legal processes to frustrate a binding commitment. Seven years later, we are getting more of the same; the Vedanta arbitration dispute reveals a similar judicial tactic. Here too, the court’s concern was not the merits of the case alone, but the determination (in this case by the Government) to keep a settled matter entangled in litigation long after the underlying issues had been adjudicated.
Prolonged litigation
What is galling is that such conduct is no longer the domain of private litigants who have the bandwidth to hire dozens of lawyers. The state itself has often become one of the largest contributors to prolonged litigation. An irony, considering that Prime Minister Narendra Modi, on taking the oath in 2014, had described reducing litigation as one of his top priorities. When governments and public authorities continue contesting awards, decrees and settlements through successive layers of judicial review, they send a damaging signal that closure is optional and that every verdict is but simply the beginning of another procedural battle.
This attitude has profound economic consequences. Investors, businesses and contractual counterparties do not judge a legal system solely by the quality of its laws or the integrity of its judges. They judge it by the certainty of outcomes and the speed of enforcement. A system in which winning a case represents only the first stage of a decades-long struggle, inevitably raises questions about predictability, investment security and the credibility of dispute resolution mechanisms.
The harsh, but uncomfortable, truth is that Indian courts repeatedly identify subterfuge when it appears before them, yet the larger ecosystem still rewards delay. Compliance is inevitably postponed until the last possible moment, adverse rulings are viewed as obstacles to be short-circuited rather than orders to be obeyed, and procedural manoeuvring experts fetch the highest price. In that sense, it is a pity that the lessons from the Ambani contempt case were never fully absorbed either by the Government or by any other institution, including the private sector.
Investors, businesses and contractual counterparties do not judge a legal system solely by the quality of its laws or the integrity of its judges. They judge it by the certainty of outcomes and the speed of enforcement












